Skip to content
Blog

Blog

Is SEO dead now that AI answers exist?

By Bhavesh Barot, Updated

A man in his thirties reads printed pages at a small office desk next to an open laptop, with a lime green pen holder on the desk.

SEO (search engine optimisation: the work of making a site easy for search engines to find and show) is not dead, because Google's AI answers link only to pages its search can show. But in our 15 November 2026 checks of "best CA firm" searches in eight Indian cities, no source we could identify in Google's AI-written answers came from that search's top 10.

So keep paying for the basics that get your firm's site found and read. A rank report alone won't tell you whether Google's AI answers name your firm, so check what those answers say about you too.

The counts below come from Google searches we ran ourselves on 15 November 2026. The rest comes from Google's own pages for site owners, read the same day.

What did Google show for "best CA firm" in eight cities?

On 15 November 2026 we ran eight Google searches of the form "best ca firm in pune", one for each city below, each searched from that city, in English, on desktop. Bengaluru ran at 02:48 UTC and the other seven at 02:49 UTC.

We ran them through DataForSEO, a service that returns the results page Google served for a search at that minute, with any AI Overview (the AI-written summary Google adds to some results pages, with links to its sources) loaded in full.

CityAI OverviewMap of local firmsSources the AI Overview linkedSources we could identifyFrom a site in that search's top 10
Bengaluruyesyes100
Mumbainoyes---
Delhiyesyes300
Puneyesyes830
Hyderabadnoyes---
Chennaiyesyes950
Ahmedabadyesyes300
Kolkatayesno1060
All eight6734140

Six of the eight searches showed an AI Overview. Seven showed the map of local firms (Google's box of nearby businesses, pinned on a map). All eight still had the ordinary list of web results.

The six AI Overviews linked 34 sources between them. Only 14 showed which site they came from. The other 20 were Google's own redirect links, which hide the site they lead to.

Of the 14 we could see, none came from a site in the same search's top 10, meaning its first ten ordinary web results.

Which sites fill the top 10 for "best CA firm" searches?

Mostly sites other than the firms' own. We sorted all 60 places in the top 10 of the six searches that showed an AI Overview by the kind of site, reading each site to decide. We name none of them.

Kind of sitePlaces in the top 10
Directories and business-list sites20
CA firms' own websites and blogs13
Social media pages, chat links and a CA discussion forum12
Document-sharing sites6
Other: a job board, a CA training site, general blogs and a magazine, an online compliance company7
Could not tell2
All six searches60

Directories, social pages and document-sharing sites took 38 of the 60 places. Eight of the 20 directory places went to sites that offer lists of businesses as sales leads.

CA firms' own websites took 13, about one place in five. Pune and Ahmedabad had four each. Delhi and Kolkata had two each, Bengaluru had one, and Chennai had none.

If your SEO is judged by a top-10 place for "best CA firm in" your city, this is the list it is judged on.

What did the AI Overviews draw on instead?

Firms' own websites, from outside the top 10. Of the 14 AI Overview sources we could identify, 10 were CA firms' own websites. Three were question-and-answer or social pages, and one was a site for CA students. None of those 14 sites appeared in the top 10 of the search that cited it.

Nine of the 10 firm pages had a title naming both the kind of firm and the city, along the lines of "CA firm in Pune".

Reviews came up in all six answers. Five gave firms' star ratings, and the sixth said one firm had a high number of reviews. In Pune, Chennai and Kolkata, the answers laid out 21 firms as cards between them (7, 8 and 6), each with a star rating and a review count, the way Google Maps shows a business.

Every one of the six ended by asking the searcher what service they needed. The examples offered included income tax return (ITR) filing, GST, audit work and company set-up. Three also asked which part of the city the searcher preferred, and three sent readers on to a directory, forum discussions or published lists of firms.

We cannot see how Google picked these firms.

Does a top-10 ranking still get you into Google's AI answers?

Sometimes. We ran the same match on every AI Overview in 61 Google searches we ran on 15 November 2026, between 02:48 and 02:56 UTC. Besides the "best CA firm" searches, they covered Indian buyers' "how to choose" questions and questions about fees and process, US buyers' questions about legal, roofing or dental work, "best lawyer" searches in US cities, and "best" and "near me" searches set in Bengaluru.

SearchesAI OverviewsSources linkedFrom a site in that search's top 10 (by address, or by Google's label for a hidden link)
8 "how to choose" questions, India87032
8 US questions about legal, roofing or dental work87129
10 "best lawyer" searches, US cities5449
7 "best CA firm" searches, Indian cities outside Bengaluru5330
8 fee and process questions, India85718
12 "best" searches set in Bengaluru, including "best CA firm"454
8 "near me" searches set in Bengaluru230
All 61 searches4028392

So 92 of the 283 sources came from a site that also ranked in that search's top 10, about one in three, matched by address or by Google's label for the site. The other 191 matched no site in it. For the eight "best CA firm" searches, the count was 0 of 34.

Google's own documentation offers one reason. It says AI Overviews may use query fan-out, which means issuing several related searches across subtopics and data sources, and can show a wider and more varied set of links than a classic search. So an AI Overview can cite a page that does not rank for the words the buyer typed, and pass over pages that do.

What did our checks not measure?

Every count above comes from one run of each search and one method. Read it with these limits:

  • We matched by site, not by page. A source counts as coming from the top 10 when its site ranked there, even if a different page from that site did. Matching page by page could only lower the 36, and could not raise the 0.
  • One run on one day. Each search ran once, on 15 November 2026 between 02:48 and 02:56 UTC. AI answers can change from one run to the next.
  • Google's redirect links hid about half the sources. In the "best CA firm" searches, 20 of 34 hid their address behind a Google link. Google still named the site for each, and none of those names matched a site in that search's top 10; 12 were Google's own listings for firms.
  • What one request saw, on desktop, in English. DataForSEO returns what Google served to its request from each city. A buyer on a phone may see a different page.
  • Google only. These searches did not ask any other AI assistant, and we did not measure clicks or enquiries.
  • Our sorting of sites. We read each site to sort it. Two blocked our request, so we sorted them by their names, and two we could not identify at all. The Mumbai and Hyderabad top 10s are not in the sort, because those searches showed no AI Overview.

How can you see what AI answers say about your firm?

Start by hand. From your office, search "best CA firm in" your city, then the questions a buyer asks before hiring a firm like yours. Note the date, whether an AI Overview appears, which firms it names and which sites it links to. Then put the same questions to an AI assistant. An answer can change the next time anyone asks, so look again on another day before you act on it.

Seen in Search does the second step for you with a standard method. We read your homepage, write buyer questions from what it says you sell, put them to AI assistants and score how the answers mention your firm. The free report a visitor gets today checks ChatGPT only. The full paid report covers ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity. The score is computed in code from published weights, and our methodology page sets out the method.

A report reads and records what the answers said. It leaves your website as it is. When it finishes it is private, and you choose whether to publish it.

Get my free report

One free report per business. Use your business email. No card.

What does Google say about SEO now?

Google says SEO still applies. Its page for site owners on AI features, last updated on 10 December 2025, says the best practices for SEO remain relevant to them, and that appearing in AI Overviews needs no extra requirements or special optimisation. To be linked in one, a page must be indexed and able to show in Google Search with a snippet (the short description under a result).

Its newer guide to optimising for generative AI features, announced on 15 May 2026 and last updated on 10 July 2026, asks whether SEO is still relevant for AI search. Its answer is "In short, yes!" The reason it gives is that these features are rooted in Google's core ranking and quality systems and pull their pages from its search index.

The same guide says that, from Google's side, work sold as answer engine optimisation or generative engine optimisation is still SEO. It says Google Search does not use special AI files such as llms.txt (a plain text file meant to tell AI tools what a site is about), so making one neither helps nor harms you there.

For a local firm, the useful line is about listings. The guide says Google Business Profiles can help your services appear in AI responses and in other Google results. The AI features page lists an up-to-date Business Profile among the basics worth doing.

Google treats all this as its existing advice. Its May 2025 post on doing well in its AI search features says the advice it has long given carries across to them.

Should a CA firm keep paying for SEO?

Yes, for the parts that our counts and Google's pages both point to. These are worth paying for:

  1. A site Google can find and index. Google's AI answers only link to pages that are indexed and can show in ordinary results. Ask whoever does your SEO to show you, in Search Console (Google's tool for site owners that reports how a site does in its search), that your service pages are indexed. Google suggests giving an outside SEO read-only access to Search Console while they audit your site.
  2. A page for each service, titled with what you do and where. Nine of the 10 firm pages the AI Overviews cited had titles naming the kind of firm and the city, and all six answers asked the searcher which service they wanted. We have not tested whether such titles win a citation. They make a page's job plain to a buyer either way.
  3. Your Google Business Profile and your reviews. Your Business Profile is the listing Google shows for your firm on Maps and in the map of local firms. That map appeared in seven of our eight searches, and reviews came up in all six AI Overviews. If you are a chartered accountant, company secretary or advocate in India, your professional body restricts advertising and soliciting work; check its current rules before you list your practice, publish fees or ask clients for reviews.
  4. Reports on what buyers see as well as your rank. Google's page on hiring an SEO suggests asking what results they expect, by when, and how they measure success. Its newer guide points site owners to a Generative AI performance report in Search Console.

Two things are not worth paying for:

  • A promise of first place, or a special line to Google. Google's page on hiring an SEO says nobody can promise a number one ranking on Google and warns against anyone claiming a special relationship with Google. It also says Google never takes money to include or rank sites in its results.
  • A report that shows only your rank for "best CA firm" in your city. In the six cities we checked, that list was mostly directories, social pages and document-sharing sites, and it supplied none of the AI Overview sources we could identify.

Some of the basics may not need paying for at all. The same Google page says the owner of a small local business can probably do much of the work themselves, starting with its SEO Starter Guide.

Questions owners ask about SEO and AI answers

Is SEO changing?
Yes. Google now adds an AI-written summary, the AI Overview, to some results pages. In eight "best CA firm" searches we ran in Indian cities on 15 November 2026 (02:48 to 02:49 UTC), six showed one. Google says the usual SEO practices still apply to them. Yet none of the 14 sources we could identify in those six answers came from a site in that search's top 10.
Is SEO replaced by AI?
No. Google's guide to its generative AI search features, last updated on 10 July 2026, says SEO is still relevant to them, because they are rooted in Google's core ranking and quality systems and draw their pages from its search index. AI has added a new place for buyers to read an answer. Making your firm's pages easy to find and understand is still what lets those answers link to you.
Is AI making SEO obsolete?
Not for a firm that wants to be found. Google says a page must be indexed and able to show in ordinary results before an AI Overview can link to it, which is SEO work. A top-10 ranking is a separate question. In 61 Google searches we ran on 15 November 2026 (02:48 to 02:56 UTC), 92 of 283 AI Overview sources came from a site in that search's top 10.
Is SEO being phased out?
No. Google still publishes its SEO Starter Guide, last updated on 10 December 2025, and its 2026 guide to generative AI search says optimising for those features is still SEO. In eight "best CA firm" searches we ran in Indian cities on 15 November 2026 (02:48 to 02:49 UTC), all eight showed the ordinary list of links, and seven showed the map of local firms.
Will SEO exist in 5 years?
Nobody can know, and nothing we have measured predicts it. Google has written that the advice it has long given carries over to its AI search features (May 2025), and that those features are rooted in its core ranking systems (2026). While AI answers draw on a search index, a firm's pages will need to be findable before those answers can link to them.
Is SEO still relevant in 2026?
Yes, by Google's account. Its guide to generative AI features, last updated on 10 July 2026, asks whether SEO is still relevant for AI search and answers yes, because those features are rooted in its core ranking and quality systems. In eight "best CA firm" searches we ran in Indian cities on 15 November 2026 (02:48 to 02:49 UTC), six showed an AI Overview and all eight showed ordinary results.
Is SEO necessary?
Being findable is necessary, but paying for it is a choice. Google says most sites in its results are found automatically, and that the owner of a small local business can probably do much of the SEO work themselves, starting with its SEO Starter Guide. A page still has to be indexed and able to show in ordinary results before Google's AI Overviews can link to it.
Who needs SEO the most?
Firms whose buyers choose a supplier by searching Google, such as chartered accountants. In the top 10 of six "best CA firm" searches we ran in Indian cities on 15 November 2026 (02:48 to 02:49 UTC), CA firms' own websites held 13 of 60 places, while directories, social pages and document-sharing sites held 38. Those are the places a firm's own site competes for.
How has SEO evolved over time?
SEO has followed Google's results page as it changed. Google's May 2025 post traces that page from plain blue links to results with images and video, from desktop to mobile-friendly pages, to voice and photo searches, and now AI answers. On 15 November 2026 (02:48 to 02:56 UTC), 191 of the 283 AI Overview sources in 61 Google searches did not match a site in that search's top 10.
What is now replacing SEO?
Nothing has replaced it. Names such as generative engine optimisation describe work aimed at AI answers, but Google's 2026 guide says that, for Google Search, this work is still SEO. The new part is checking whether AI answers to your buyers' questions name your firm. Seen in Search's free report checks ChatGPT's answers; the full paid report adds Google AI Overviews and Perplexity.
Get my free report

One free report per business, private unless you publish it. Use your business email. No card. Questions about the report? Contact us.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central, AI features and your website, last updated 10 December 2025, read 15 November 2026.
  2. Google Search Central, Optimizing your website for generative AI features on Google Search, last updated 10 July 2026, read 15 November 2026.
  3. Google Search Central blog (John Mueller), A new resource for optimizing for generative AI in Google Search, 15 May 2026, read 15 November 2026.
  4. Google Search Central blog (John Mueller), Top ways to ensure your content performs well in Google's AI experiences on Search, 21 May 2025, read 15 November 2026.
  5. Google Search Central, Search Engine Optimization (SEO) Starter Guide, last updated 10 December 2025, read 15 November 2026.
  6. Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO?, last updated 5 June 2026, read 15 November 2026.
  7. Our own check: Google results for "best CA firm" searches in eight Indian cities, each searched from that city, run through DataForSEO's Google search data, 15 November 2026, 02:48 to 02:49 UTC.
  8. Our own check: the sources of the 40 AI Overviews in 61 Google searches, each matched by site against the same search's top 10, run through DataForSEO's Google search data, 15 November 2026, 02:48 to 02:56 UTC.
  9. Our own count: the kinds of sites in the top 10 of the six "best CA firm" searches that showed an AI Overview, sorted by reading each site on 15 November 2026. No site or business is named.