Skip to content

How do you choose a legal marketing agency?

By Bhavesh Barot

Updated
Reading time
8 min read
Guide number
No. 039
A lawyer in a navy blazer asks a question across a meeting table to two marketing consultants with an open laptop, a lime green notebook on the table.
On this page
  1. 01What does a legal marketing agency do?
  2. 02Start by deciding what you need
  3. 03Questions to ask every agency
  4. 04Contract terms that protect your firm
  5. 05Red flags
  6. 06The ethics rules are still yours
  7. 07How do AI answers change what an agency should do?
  8. 08How do you measure an agency's work?
  9. 09How does Seen in Search help?
  10. 10Questions lawyers ask about legal marketing agencies

A legal marketing agency helps a law firm get found and get hired: through its website, search, ads, directory profiles, reviews and, more and more, the answers AI assistants give when people ask for a lawyer. There are hundreds of agencies that work only with law firms, and many more general agencies that take legal clients. They vary from excellent to harmful, and the sales pitch rarely shows which is which.

This guide is for owners and managing partners of small and mid-size US firms. It covers what an agency should do for you, the questions to ask before signing, the contract terms that protect you, the red flags, the ethics rules that still apply to you, and how to tell whether the agency is working.

Most offer some mix of these services:

ServiceWhat it coversWho usually needs it
WebsiteDesign, build, hosting, practice-area pagesFirms with an old or thin site
SEOPractice-area content, Google Business Profile, directory profiles, technical fixes, linksMost firms, for lasting visibility
Paid searchGoogle search ads and Local Services AdsFirms needing cases quickly, or in competitive practices
Social and videoFacebook and Instagram ads, YouTube, short videosConsumer practices such as PI, family, immigration
ContentArticles and FAQs answering client questionsFirms whose clients research before calling
Intake supportCall tracking, call answering, intake scriptsFirms losing calls or not tracking them
AI visibilityChecking and improving whether AI assistants name the firmFirms whose clients ask ChatGPT or read Google's AI answers

You don't need all of them. Decide what you need first, based on where your clients come from and where you're losing them.

Start by deciding what you need

Before talking to agencies, answer three questions:

  1. Where do our signed cases come from today? Referrals, search, directories, ads, past clients. If you don't know, start tracking.
  2. What's the gap? Not enough inquiries, the wrong kind of inquiries, or inquiries that don't sign?
  3. What can we handle in-house? Some firms can write content or ask for reviews themselves and only need help with ads or technical work.

An agency that hears "we need more cases" will sell you everything. An agency that hears "we get enough calls but too many are outside our practice areas" can solve a specific problem.

Questions to ask every agency

QuestionWhat a good answer sounds like
What would you do in the first 90 days, specifically?A written plan with named tasks, not "a custom strategy"
How will you measure success?Signed cases and cost per signed case, not just traffic or rankings
Who will do the work?Named people, and whether any work is outsourced
Do you work with other firms in my practice and city?A clear answer; many agencies limit this to avoid conflicts
Who owns the website, ad accounts, content and profiles?You do, in writing
What happens if we leave?You keep everything, with a clean handover
How do you handle state bar advertising rules?A process for review, and acknowledgment that you're responsible
Can we speak to current clients?Yes, a few firms you can call

Ask to see example reports from another client, with names removed. If the report shows only charts of traffic and rankings, ask how they connect that to signed cases.

Contract terms that protect your firm

Read the contract before the proposal excites you:

  • Ownership. Your domain, website, content, Google Business Profile, ad accounts and call tracking numbers should be yours, in your name. Some agencies build sites on their own platforms and keep them if you leave.
  • Term and exit. Long lock-ins are common. Prefer month-to-month after a short initial term, or a clear exit clause.
  • Ad spend. Ad budgets should be paid to Google or Meta directly, or shown separately from the agency's fee, so you can see what's spent.
  • Exclusivity. If it matters, put it in writing: no other client in your practice area in your market.
  • Reporting. Monthly reports with agreed measures, and access to the raw data.
Get my free report

See whether AI assistants such as ChatGPT name your firm for the questions your clients ask. One free report per business, with a business email you verify. No card.

Red flags

  • Promises you can't check. Promises of first-place rankings, a set number of cases, or a place in ChatGPT answers. Nobody controls Google's rankings or what an AI writes.
  • Vague work. "We'll optimize your presence" without saying what will be done.
  • Fake reviews or paid links. Any suggestion of buying reviews, writing reviews for you, or buying links breaks Google's policies, the FTC's rule on fake reviews and, for reviews, ABA Model Rule 7.2's limits on paying for recommendations.
  • Doorway pages. Plans to publish dozens of near-identical city pages. Google's spam policies target these.
  • Pay-per-lead deals that look like referral fees. Paying for leads can be allowed, but arrangements that pay per signed case or share fees can break Rule 7.2 or your state's version. Check with your state bar's ethics guidance.
  • No access. If you can't log in to your own ad account or analytics, you can't check anything.

The ethics rules are still yours

Hiring an agency doesn't move responsibility. Under ABA Model Rule 5.3, lawyers must make reasonable efforts to ensure that people they work with outside the firm act in line with the lawyer's professional obligations. Everything the agency publishes for you, your website, ads, social posts, review replies, is your lawyer advertising under your state's rules, usually based on Rules 7.1 to 7.3.

Set a review step: someone at the firm approves every ad and every page before it goes live, against your state's rules on misleading claims, specialty claims, past results and disclaimers. Agencies that work only with lawyers should already have a process; ask to see it.

How do AI answers change what an agency should do?

People now ask ChatGPT "who is a good immigration lawyer in Houston" or see a Google AI summary naming a few firms, with links to sources such as legal directories, review sites, news and firm websites. You can't buy a place in those answers.

An agency should be able to tell you whether AI assistants name your firm today, which sources they cite, and what it will do about it. Most of that work overlaps with good SEO: clear practice-area pages, complete directory profiles, consistent details and honest reviews. Our law firm SEO guide covers that groundwork, and GEO vs SEO explains how the two kinds of work fit together. Ask any agency how it measures AI visibility, and whether you can read the actual answers.

How do you measure an agency's work?

Agree on measures before you start:

  1. Signed cases by source, from your intake records.
  2. Cost per signed case, including the agency's fee and ad spend.
  3. Inquiries by source and practice area, from call tracking and forms.
  4. Search Console data: searches and clicks for your practice pages.
  5. AI visibility: whether AI assistants name your firm for a fixed set of client questions, checked monthly.

Give an SEO program several months before judging it; give paid ads a month or two of data. Then decide on numbers, not on how the monthly call feels.

How does Seen in Search help?

A Seen in Search report gives you an independent view of one of those measures. It reads your homepage, writes buyer questions based on what the homepage says you offer, puts them to AI assistants such as ChatGPT, and scores how visible you are in the answers, in code, with fixed, published weights. You see each answer word for word, the competitors it named, the score, and a ranked list of what to fix first. Our methodology page shows how the score is worked out, and the free AI visibility check page shows what the report includes. Reports are private when they finish. It isn't legal advice on your state's rules.

Questions lawyers ask about legal marketing agencies

How much does a legal marketing agency cost?
It varies widely by services, market and agency size, from a modest monthly retainer for a small firm's SEO to large budgets for competitive personal injury advertising. Ask for fees and ad spend to be shown separately, and judge the total against cost per signed case. See each agency's own proposal for prices.
Should a law firm hire a legal-only agency?
Legal-only agencies know bar advertising rules, intake and legal directories, which saves time. General agencies can be strong too, if they understand your rules. What matters more is a clear plan, honest reporting, your ownership of everything and measures tied to signed cases.
What should a legal marketing agency report each month?
Inquiries and signed cases by source, cost per signed case, work completed, search data from Search Console, ad results and changes made. A good report also says what didn't work and what changes next month. Ask for access to the raw data, not just a summary.
How long should a law firm stay with a marketing agency?
Long enough to judge the work fairly: several months for SEO, a month or two of data for ads. After that, stay while the numbers work. Avoid contracts that lock you in for long periods without an exit clause, and make sure you keep your accounts if you leave.
Can a marketing agency write reviews for my law firm?
No. Reviews must come from real clients. Agency-written or purchased reviews break Google's policies, the FTC's rule on fake reviews and lawyer advertising rules. An agency can help set up review requests to every client, which is allowed when you offer nothing in return.
Who is responsible if my agency breaks bar advertising rules?
You are. Under ABA Model Rule 5.3, lawyers must make reasonable efforts to ensure that non-lawyers they work with follow the lawyer's professional obligations. Approve all ads and pages before they go live, and check them against your state's rules.
What is the difference between SEO and PPC agencies for lawyers?
SEO agencies work on your website, Business Profile, directory profiles and content so you're found without paying per click. PPC agencies manage paid ads such as Google search ads. Many agencies do both. SEO builds over months; ads bring calls quickly but stop when spending stops.
Do legal marketing agencies help with AI search?
Some do. Ask how the agency checks whether AI assistants like ChatGPT and Google's AI name your firm, whether you can read the actual answers, and what it does to improve them. Much of the work overlaps with good SEO. Be wary of anyone who promises placement in AI answers.
Should my firm own its website if an agency builds it?
Yes. Your domain, site files, content and accounts should be in your name. Some agencies build on their own platforms and keep the site if you leave, which forces a rebuild. Put ownership and handover terms in the contract before work starts.
How do I compare proposals from legal marketing agencies?
Compare the specific work promised, who does it, the measures used, contract length, ownership terms and total cost including ad spend. Call current clients. Choose the agency whose plan addresses your actual gap, not the one with the longest list of services.
Get my free report

One free report per business, private unless you publish it. Use a business email you verify. No card. Questions about the report? Contact us.

Sources

Written by Bhavesh Barot. Last checked and updated .

Keep reading

All guides

8 min read

How do you use Google AI Mode?

How to open and use Google AI Mode: asking questions, follow-ups, voice and images, checking sources, and how business owners can see what buyers see.