Skip to content

Criminal defense lawyer marketing: how do you get the call?

By Bhavesh Barot

Updated
Reading time
8 min read
Guide number
No. 023
A criminal defense lawyer in a grey suit talks calmly on his phone by a large office window, a lime green pen on the desk.
On this page
  1. 01How do people search for a criminal defense lawyer?
  2. 02Start with intake, not ads
  3. 03Build a page for each charge you handle
  4. 04Get the local results right
  5. 05Reviews: valuable, and sensitive
  6. 06Results and the ethics rules
  7. 07Paid ads for defense firms
  8. 08How do AI answers change defense marketing?
  9. 09How do you measure what works?
  10. 10How does Seen in Search help?
  11. 11Questions defense lawyers ask about marketing

Criminal defense marketing is different from most legal marketing in one way: timing. Someone has just been arrested, or a family member has, or a letter has arrived from a prosecutor. They search on a phone, often at night, and call the first firm that looks capable and answers. Marketing for a defense firm is about being found in those minutes and being reachable when the call comes.

This guide covers what that means in practice for a US defense firm: the searches people make, the pages to build, intake, reviews within the ethics rules, ads, and how AI answers are changing who gets named.

How do people search for a criminal defense lawyer?

SituationTypical searchWhat they need to see fast
Just arrested, or a relative was"criminal lawyer near me", "DUI lawyer open now"A phone number that's answered now
Charged, court date set"[charge] lawyer [county]", "first offense DUI [state]"Experience with that charge in that court
Researching"what happens at an arraignment in [state]", "can a DUI be reduced to reckless driving"A clear, honest answer
Checking a name"[firm] reviews", "[attorney] DUI"Reviews, bio, track record within the rules

Most calls come from the first two rows. Both need a firm that shows up locally and answers the phone.

Start with intake, not ads

The best marketing fails if calls go to voicemail at 11 p.m. Before spending on visibility:

  1. Decide your hours. If you take calls around the clock, say so everywhere. If you don't, use an answering service that can take details and book a callback.
  2. Answer fast. People who've just been arrested call several firms. The first to answer often gets the case.
  3. Make it easy on a phone. A tap-to-call number on every page, and a short form.
  4. Track every call to its source, and its outcome.

Build a page for each charge you handle

A single "Criminal Defense" page can't answer the searches above. Build pages for the charges you want: DUI or DWI, drug possession, assault, domestic violence, theft, white-collar, juvenile, probation violations, expungement. Each should cover:

  • the charge in plain words, for your state;
  • what happens next, step by step, from arrest to trial;
  • possible penalties and what can affect them, stated carefully with a note to get advice on the person's own case;
  • what to do and not to do right now (for example, not discussing the case with others);
  • the courts and counties you appear in;
  • the attorneys who handle it, linked to their bios;
  • how to reach you now.

Keep content current as laws change. Note the date you last checked the law on the page.

Get the local results right

For "criminal lawyer near me", the map results usually appear near the top. Your Google Business Profile decides how you appear:

  • your real firm name, without added keywords;
  • a real office where you meet clients, not a virtual office;
  • the right category, such as "Criminal justice attorney" or "DUI attorney";
  • accurate hours, and whether you take calls after hours;
  • real photos of the office and team.

Claim your profiles on legal directories too, such as Avvo, Justia, FindLaw and your state and local bar directories. Keep your details identical everywhere.

Get my free report

See whether ChatGPT names your firm when people ask for a criminal defense lawyer in your area. One free report per business. Use your business email. No card.

Reviews: valuable, and sensitive

Many defense clients don't want to leave a public review, since it would reveal they were charged. Ask anyway, every client, with a direct link, and accept that many will decline. Offer nothing in return: ABA Model Rule 7.2 limits giving anything of value for recommendations, and the FTC's rule bans fake reviews.

Never reveal anything about a client's case in a reply. Rule 1.6 protects client information, and several state bar ethics opinions have found lawyers violated it by responding to negative reviews with case details. Keep replies short and general.

Results and the ethics rules

Defense firms often want to publish dismissals and acquittals. Rule 7.1 forbids misleading communications, and the ABA's comments note that past results can mislead if presented so that a reasonable person would expect the same outcome regardless of their own facts. Many states require disclaimers on results, and some require client consent to publish. Check your state's rules, and present results with context.

Watch the words "expert" and "specialist" too; most states limit them to lawyers certified by an approved body.

Search ads and Local Services Ads can bring urgent calls right away. Defense keywords such as "DUI lawyer" are expensive in many cities. To keep waste down:

  • schedule ads for hours when calls are answered;
  • target people located in your area, not people searching about it from elsewhere;
  • add negative keywords like "jobs", "salary", "free legal advice" and "public defender" if you don't want those searches;
  • send each ad to the matching charge page;
  • measure cost per signed case, not per click.

Our law firm PPC guide goes through the setup in detail.

How do AI answers change defense marketing?

Ask ChatGPT "best DUI lawyer in Phoenix" or search similar on Google, and you'll often see a short AI answer naming a few firms, with links to sources such as legal directories, review sites, news and firm websites. You can't buy a place in that answer.

In our checks of Google's AI Overviews for "best lawyer" searches in US cities, many sources cited came from sites outside that search's top ten results; our post on whether SEO is dead has the counts. So a firm can rank well and still be left out, or be named because of a strong directory profile.

What helps: clear charge pages, complete directory profiles, consistent details and honest reviews. To check, ask the AI tools the questions an arrested person's family would ask, with your city, from a private window, and note whether you're named and which sources are cited. Our law firm SEO guide covers the groundwork.

How do you measure what works?

Track each inquiry to its source: Business Profile, website page, ad campaign, directory, referral. Track which became signed cases, and the fee. Work out cost per signed case by source each month and shift budget accordingly. Referrals from other lawyers and former clients often turn out to be the best source; keep those relationships warm within your state's rules.

Families often make the first call, not the person charged, so write your pages for both. A parent searching at midnight needs to know what happens at a bail hearing and how to reach you, in plain words.

How does Seen in Search help?

A Seen in Search report shows whether AI tools name your firm. It reads your homepage, writes buyer questions based on what you offer, puts them to AI assistants and scores how visible you are in the answers, in code, with fixed, published weights. The free report checks ChatGPT. The full paid report covers ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Perplexity. Our methodology page explains the score. Reports are private when they finish. It isn't legal advice on your state's advertising rules.

Questions defense lawyers ask about marketing

What is the best marketing for a criminal defense lawyer?
Being reachable and visible at the moment of need. That means fast intake, a strong Google Business Profile, clear pages for each charge you handle, complete legal directory profiles and honest reviews. Paid ads add speed. Referrals from other lawyers and former clients often bring the best cases. Track cost per signed case to see what works for you.
How do criminal defense lawyers get clients?
Mostly through search (Google, map results and directories), referrals from other lawyers and former clients, and paid ads. Speed matters: arrested people and their families call several firms, and the first that answers often gets hired. Strong online presence plus fast intake is the core.
Should a defense firm answer calls 24 hours a day?
Many do, because arrests happen at night and on weekends. If you can't staff phones around the clock, use an answering service that takes details and books a callback quickly. State your hours honestly on your site and Business Profile, so callers know what to expect.
Can defense lawyers publish case results?
Usually yes, within your state's rules. Rule 7.1 forbids misleading communications, and many states require disclaimers that results depend on each case's facts. Some require client consent. Give context, avoid implying any outcome for a new client, and check your state bar's rules before publishing.
How do defense lawyers get reviews when clients want privacy?
Ask every client, explain that a review can use initials or first name only, and accept that many will decline. Never offer anything in return. Reviews from clients in expungement or dismissed cases may be easier to get. Never reveal case details in replies.
Is SEO worth it for criminal defense lawyers?
Usually, alongside ads. Charge-specific pages for your state and courts can rank for urgent local searches and feed the sources AI tools cite. It takes months to build and needs content kept current as laws change. Ads cover the gap while SEO grows.
Are Google Ads worth it for criminal defense?
They can be, if calls are answered and campaigns are tightly targeted. Defense keywords are expensive in many cities, so schedule ads for staffed hours, target your area, add negative keywords and measure cost per signed case. Local Services Ads are another option for many legal categories.
What legal directories matter for defense lawyers?
Avvo, Justia, FindLaw, Martindale-Hubbell and Lawyers.com are widely used in the US, plus your state and local bar directories. Many rank for defense searches and appear as sources in AI answers. Claim free profiles, complete them and keep details identical everywhere.
Does ChatGPT recommend criminal defense lawyers?
It can, when asked for a lawyer in a city with search on. It usually names a few firms and links to directories, review sites and firm websites. Which firms it names varies by question and between runs. Ask it the questions your clients' families ask and look at the sources it uses.
What ethics rules apply to defense lawyer marketing?
Your state's version of the ABA Model Rules, especially 7.1 (no misleading communications), 7.2 (advertising, specialty claims, no paying for recommendations) and 7.3 (solicitation), plus Rule 1.6 on confidentiality in review replies. Some states add rules on contacting people after arrests. Check your state bar's rules.
Get my free report

One free report per business, private unless you publish it. Use your business email. No card. Questions about the report? Contact us.

Sources

Written by Bhavesh Barot. Last checked and updated .

Keep reading

All guides