Skip to content

How do you choose a dental marketing agency?

By Bhavesh Barot

Updated
Reading time
8 min read
Guide number
No. 035
A dentist with short grey hair reviews printed pages at a table beside her practice manager, a lime green mug in front of them.
On this page
  1. 01What does a dental marketing agency do?
  2. 02Know your gap before you call anyone
  3. 03Questions to ask every agency
  4. 04HIPAA and patient data
  5. 05Reviews: what an agency may and may not do
  6. 06Contract terms to check
  7. 07Red flags
  8. 08How do AI answers affect what an agency should do?
  9. 09Ask for a trial project first
  10. 10How do you judge results?
  11. 11How does Seen in Search help?
  12. 12Questions practices ask about dental marketing agencies

A dental marketing agency helps a practice bring in new patients: through its website, Google Business Profile, search, ads, reviews, social media and now the answers AI assistants give when people ask for a dentist. Many agencies work only with dental practices; others are general agencies with dental clients. The difference between a good and a poor one shows up a year later, in how many new patients you booked and what each cost.

This guide is for practice owners and office managers in the US. It covers what an agency should do, the questions to ask, contract terms, patient privacy and review rules, red flags and how to judge results. For the marketing work itself, see our dental marketing guide and our dental SEO guide.

What does a dental marketing agency do?

ServiceWhat it coversWhen a practice needs it
WebsiteDesign, hosting, treatment and insurance pages, online bookingOld, slow or thin website
Local SEOGoogle Business Profile, listings, treatment pages, technical fixesNot showing in "dentist near me" results
Paid searchGoogle Ads for urgent and high-value treatmentsNeed new patients quickly, or promoting implants or aligners
ReviewsReview requests after visits, reply templatesFew or old reviews
Social mediaPosts, ads, before-and-after content with consentCosmetic and orthodontic work, community presence
Patient communicationReminders, recall, reactivationPatients not returning for hygiene visits
AI visibilityChecking whether AI assistants name the practicePatients asking ChatGPT or reading Google's AI answers

Few practices need all of these. Start with where new patients come from today and where you lose them.

Know your gap before you call anyone

Ask your front desk to record how every new patient found you for a month. Then look at:

  1. Volume: are enough people calling or booking?
  2. Mix: are you getting the patients you want, such as implant or family patients, or mostly price shoppers?
  3. Conversion: do callers book, and do booked patients show up?

If calls are fine but bookings are low, the fix may be front desk training or online booking, not more marketing. An honest agency will say so.

Questions to ask every agency

QuestionA good answer
What exactly will you do in the first 90 days?A written task list, not "a custom plan"
How will we measure success?New patients booked, by source, and cost per new patient
Who does the work, and is any outsourced?Named people and honest disclosure
Do you work with other practices near us?A clear answer, and an exclusivity option if it matters to you
Who owns the website, domain, ad accounts and profiles?You, in writing
Will you sign a HIPAA business associate agreement?Yes, if they handle patient information
What happens if we leave?You keep everything, with a clean handover
Can we speak to current clients?Yes

HIPAA and patient data

Many marketing services touch patient information: review request tools that use patient phone numbers, recall emails, call recordings, online booking forms. Under HIPAA, a vendor that handles protected health information for your practice is generally a business associate, and you need a business associate agreement with them. Ask every agency which patient data its tools use, where it's stored and whether it will sign one.

Watch tracking on your website too. HHS guidance has addressed tracking technologies such as analytics pixels on health care websites, and how they can expose patient information; a federal court set aside part of that guidance in 2024, but tracking on booking and patient pages still needs care. Ask the agency what tracking it installs, especially on booking and contact pages. Your HIPAA compliance adviser should review the setup.

Get my free report

See whether AI assistants such as ChatGPT name your practice for the questions patients ask. One free report per business, with a business email you verify. No card.

Reviews: what an agency may and may not do

An agency can set up automatic review requests after visits, which is good practice. It must not write reviews, buy them or ask only happy patients. Google removes fake and incentivized reviews, and the FTC's rule bans fake reviews and review suppression.

Review replies need care under HIPAA. A reply that confirms the reviewer is a patient or mentions treatment can disclose protected information, and HHS has acted against dental practices for this. If the agency writes replies, insist on a template that thanks the reviewer without confirming anything, and approve replies to negative reviews yourself.

Contract terms to check

  • Ownership: domain, website, content, Business Profile and ad accounts in the practice's name.
  • Term: short initial term, then month-to-month or a clear exit clause.
  • Ad spend: paid directly to Google or Meta, or shown separately from the agency's fee.
  • Platform lock-in: if the site is built on the agency's own platform, what happens when you leave?
  • Reporting: monthly, with access to raw data such as Google Ads, Analytics and Search Console.
  • Business associate agreement: where patient data is involved.

Red flags

  • Promises of first place on Google, a set number of new patients, or a spot in ChatGPT answers.
  • Fake or incentivized reviews, or "reputation management" that means hiding bad reviews.
  • Dozens of near-identical town pages for places where you have no office.
  • Specialty claims the agency writes for a general dentist, such as "implant specialist". State dental boards regulate the word "specialist".
  • No access to your own accounts and data.
  • Reports with only traffic charts, never new patients.

How do AI answers affect what an agency should do?

Patients ask ChatGPT "who's a good family dentist in Cary that takes Delta Dental" or see a Google AI summary naming practices, with links to sources such as practice sites, review sites and insurance directories. You can't buy a place in those answers.

Ask any agency whether AI assistants name your practice today, which sources they cite, and how it will improve that. Most of the work overlaps with local SEO: clear treatment and insurance pages, consistent listings, especially insurance directories, and honest reviews. Ask whether you can read the actual answers, not just a summary score.

Ask for a trial project first

If you're unsure about an agency, start with a defined project, such as fixing your Google Business Profile and building two treatment pages, before signing a long retainer. You'll see how they communicate, how fast they work and how they report.

How do you judge results?

  1. New patients booked, by source, from your front desk and booking system.
  2. Cost per new patient by channel, including the agency fee.
  3. Calls and bookings from your Business Profile and website.
  4. Search Console data for treatment and location pages.
  5. AI visibility for a fixed set of patient questions, checked monthly.

Give local SEO several months; give ads a month or two of data. Then decide on the numbers.

How does Seen in Search help?

A Seen in Search report gives you an independent check on one of those measures. It reads your homepage, writes buyer questions based on what the homepage says you offer, puts them to AI assistants such as ChatGPT, and scores how visible you are in the answers, in code, with fixed, published weights. You see each answer word for word, the competitors it named, the score, and a ranked list of what to fix first. Our methodology page shows how the score is worked out, and the free AI visibility check page shows what the report includes. Reports are private when they finish.

Questions practices ask about dental marketing agencies

How much does a dental marketing agency cost?
It depends on the services, your market and the agency, from a modest monthly fee for local SEO to larger budgets including ad spend for implants or aligners. Ask for fees and ad spend shown separately, and compare the total with new patients booked. See each agency's own proposal for prices.
Is a dental-only marketing agency better?
Dental-only agencies know insurance pages, HIPAA concerns, state dental board rules and dental software, which saves time. General agencies can do well too. What matters more is a clear plan, honest reporting tied to new patients, your ownership of everything and a willingness to sign a business associate agreement where needed.
Does a dental marketing agency need a business associate agreement?
If the agency or its tools handle protected health information, such as patient names and phone numbers for review requests or recall messages, it's generally a business associate under HIPAA and you need an agreement. Ask your HIPAA compliance adviser to confirm for your setup.
What should a dental marketing report include?
New patients booked by source, cost per new patient, calls and bookings, ad results, Search Console data, work completed and plans for next month. It should also say what didn't work. Ask for access to the underlying accounts as well as the summary.
How long before dental marketing shows results?
Paid ads can bring calls within days. Local SEO and reviews take several months to build. Website changes help once they're live and indexed. Agree on what you'll judge at three, six and twelve months before you start, so expectations are clear on both sides.
Can a marketing agency manage our Google reviews?
It can send review requests and help draft reply templates. It must not write fake reviews, buy reviews or hide negative ones. Replies must not confirm that someone is a patient or mention treatment, because of HIPAA. Approve replies to negative reviews yourself.
Should we sign a long contract with a dental marketing agency?
Be careful. Long lock-ins with no exit clause leave you stuck if results don't come. Prefer a short initial term then month-to-month, and make sure your domain, website and accounts stay in the practice's name if you leave. Read the exit terms before you sign.
Do dental marketing agencies handle social media?
Many do. Social media suits cosmetic, orthodontic and community content, with written patient consent for any photos. It does more for engagement and word of mouth than for patients searching for a dentist today. Make sure social work doesn't crowd out local search basics.
Can a marketing agency help us show up in ChatGPT?
Some say they can. Ask how they check whether AI assistants name your practice, whether you can read the actual answers, and what work they do. Much of it overlaps with local SEO. Be wary of anyone who promises placement; nobody controls what an AI writes.
How do I compare dental marketing proposals?
Compare the specific work, who does it, how success is measured, contract terms, ownership, HIPAA handling and total cost including ad spend. Call current clients. Choose the agency whose plan fixes your actual gap, whether that's visibility, patient mix or bookings.
Get my free report

One free report per business, private unless you publish it. Use a business email you verify. No card. Questions about the report? Contact us.

Sources

Written by Bhavesh Barot. Last checked and updated .

Keep reading

All guides