Dental reviews: how does a practice get more, and reply safely?
By Bhavesh Barot
- Updated
- Reading time
- 8 min read
- Guide number
- No. 036

On this page
- 01Why do dental reviews matter so much?
- 02Where should a dental practice collect reviews?
- 03How do you get more reviews, the honest way?
- 04What's not allowed?
- 05How do you reply to reviews without breaking HIPAA?
- 06What should you do about a bad review?
- 07Train the front desk
- 08How do reviews show up in AI answers?
- 09How do you measure your review program?
- 10How does Seen in Search help?
- 11Questions practices ask about dental reviews
Online reviews are one of the first things a new patient checks before booking a dentist, and one of the signals Google uses to decide which practices appear in the map results. They also feed what AI assistants say when someone asks "who's a good dentist near me". For a dental practice, reviews come with one extra complication most businesses don't have: HIPAA, which limits what you can say when you reply.
This guide covers how to get more reviews honestly, the rules on incentives and fake reviews, how to reply to good and bad reviews without disclosing patient information, and how reviews show up in AI answers. It isn't legal advice; check your approach with your HIPAA compliance adviser.
Why do dental reviews matter so much?
- Patients read them. Choosing a dentist is personal. Reviews answer questions your website can't: is the staff kind, is the wait long, does the dentist explain things?
- Google uses them. Google says local rankings depend on relevance, distance and prominence, and review count and rating are part of prominence.
- AI assistants repeat them. When ChatGPT or Google's AI summarizes local dentists, it often draws on review sites and may repeat themes from reviews.
Where should a dental practice collect reviews?
| Platform | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Feeds the map results and Google's AI answers; the first place most patients look | |
| Yelp | Popular in some US cities; doesn't allow you to ask for reviews |
| Recommendations show on your page | |
| Health directories and booking sites | Patients use them to find and book dentists |
| Insurance carrier directories | Some show ratings next to in-network dentists |
Focus most effort on Google, then whichever other site patients in your area use. Note Yelp's policy: it asks businesses not to solicit reviews at all.
How do you get more reviews, the honest way?
- Ask every patient. Ask everyone, including patients who seem unhappy. Asking selectively is review gating, which Google's policies forbid.
- Ask at the right time. After the visit, by text or email, while the experience is fresh.
- Make it one tap. Send a direct link to your Google review form, which you can get from your Business Profile.
- Say it at checkout. A quick "we'd love your feedback; you'll get a text with a link" from the front desk raises response.
- Follow up once. Then stop.
- Thank people who review, in a reply that doesn't confirm they're a patient.
Many practice management and patient communication tools automate review requests. If a tool uses patient names and phone numbers, it handles protected health information, and the vendor is generally a business associate under HIPAA. Make sure you have a business associate agreement.
What's not allowed?
- Incentives. No discounts, gifts, raffle entries or free whitening for reviews. Google removes incentivized reviews, and the FTC's rule on consumer reviews bans buying reviews and offering incentives conditioned on a positive review.
- Fake reviews. Staff, family or agency-written reviews, or reviews posing as patients. Google removes them, and the FTC's rule bans them.
- Review gating. Sending only happy patients to Google and unhappy ones to a private form. Google's policies forbid it.
- Suppression. Threats or pressure to remove negative reviews. The FTC's rule covers review suppression too.
- Paying for "review management" that hides bad reviews. If a vendor promises to make bad reviews disappear, ask how.
See whether AI assistants such as ChatGPT name your practice when patients ask for a dentist. One free report per business, with a business email you verify. No card.
How do you reply to reviews without breaking HIPAA?
HIPAA's privacy rule protects patient information, including the fact that someone is your patient. A reply that confirms someone visited, mentions their treatment, appointment or bill, or responds to details they posted can be a disclosure, even when the patient shared those details first. The HHS Office for Civil Rights has settled with dental practices over review replies that disclosed patient information.
Safe reply to a positive review: "Thank you for taking the time to share this. We appreciate it."
Safe reply to a negative review: "We take all feedback seriously. We can't discuss anyone's care online because of privacy rules, but we'd welcome a call to the office to talk."
What to avoid in any reply:
- "Thanks for coming in," "we enjoyed seeing you," or anything confirming a visit;
- any mention of a procedure, appointment, bill or insurance;
- correcting the reviewer's account of their treatment, even if it's wrong;
- names of staff involved in the patient's care, if that confirms the visit.
Write a short set of approved replies and have one person, ideally the practice owner or manager, handle negative ones.
What should you do about a bad review?
- Don't reply in anger. Wait a day.
- Reply with the safe template, inviting them to call.
- Call them if you can identify them from your records, privately, to resolve the issue.
- Fix what's real. If several reviews mention long waits, the problem is the schedule, not the reviews.
- Report reviews that break Google's policies, such as spam, off-topic content or reviews from people who were never patients. Google decides whether to remove them.
A few negative reviews among many positive ones look normal. A perfect rating can look suspicious to patients.
Train the front desk
Your front desk shapes reviews more than any tool. Patients review the whole visit: the phone call, the wait, the billing conversation. Brief the team on why reviews matter, how to mention the review text at checkout, and what never to say online. Share good reviews with the team; they earned them. When a negative theme repeats, discuss it at a team meeting and decide what changes. Reviews are feedback first and marketing second.
How do reviews show up in AI answers?
Ask ChatGPT "who's a good family dentist in Raleigh" with search on, or search the same on Google, and the answer often names a few practices and cites review sites and directories. It may repeat themes such as "gentle with anxious patients" or "long waits". Those themes come from what patients wrote.
So steady, honest reviews do two jobs: they help your map ranking and they give AI assistants a fair picture of your practice. Our dental SEO guide covers the rest of the groundwork, and our dental marketing guide the wider plan.
If you use a patient communication tool to send review requests, check its settings: make sure it sends to every patient after a visit. Sending requests only to patients who rated the practice highly in a survey would be review gating.
How do you measure your review program?
- Reviews received per month, on Google and your second platform.
- Share of patients asked who leave a review.
- Average rating trend over months.
- Themes in negative reviews, reviewed quarterly.
- Whether AI assistants describe your practice fairly, checked with a fixed set of patient questions.
How does Seen in Search help?
A Seen in Search report shows what AI assistants say about your practice. It reads your homepage, writes buyer questions based on what the homepage says you offer, puts them to AI assistants such as ChatGPT, and scores how visible you are in the answers, in code, with fixed, published weights. You see each answer word for word, the competitors it named, the score, and a ranked list of what to fix first. Our methodology page shows how the score is worked out. Reports are private when they finish.
Questions practices ask about dental reviews
How do dentists get more Google reviews?
Can a dentist offer a discount for a review?
Can a dentist respond to a patient review?
What happens if a dental office violates HIPAA in a review reply?
How should a dentist respond to a negative review?
Can a dental practice remove a bad Google review?
Is it legal to ask patients for reviews?
How many Google reviews does a dentist need?
Do reviews help a dental practice show up in ChatGPT?
Should a dental practice reply to every review?
One free report per business, private unless you publish it. Use a business email you verify. No card. Questions about the report? Contact us.


